Manga Review: The Alchemist Who Survived Now Dreams of a Quiet Life (DO NOT PURCHASE)

Manga Review: The Alchemist Who Survived Now Dreams of a Quiet Life (DO NOT PURCHASE)

Title: The Alchemist Who Survived Now Dreams of a Quiet Life 生き残り錬金術師は街で静かに暮らしたい

Mangaka: Usata Nonohara, Guru Mizoguchi, Ox

US Publisher: Yen Press

Status: Ongoing.

Level: Secondary.

Reader’s Advisory Tags: Seinen, fantasy, not recommended.

Anime: None.

Content Warnings: This manga depicts slavery in an uncomfortable context. There is torture and abuse of slaves, as well as a main character justifying her purchase of a slave.

So, I’ve had a long list of manga I needed to review. I had plans to review xxxHolic, My Love Story, and Hana-Kimi for awhile now. But this past weekend at Anime NYC a publisher gave away a volume of manga that you will probably want to not purchase for a school library. (Anime NYC was great and merits its own post, but this is the thing I feel most pressed to write about.)

Let me say, generally, I don’t normally feel comfortable advising fully against a series. Most of the time, I think any book has value so long as it’s not pornographic or depicts morally reprehensible acts. This is the first time I was actively given a free book that I then chose to not add to the collection because I felt its contents would be actively damaging to my population.

My population is 95% Black. This book depicts slavery, and the main character actively purchases a slave and reasons that his enslavement is in fact useful to her. It perpetuates the horrific trope of “the good master” by having her be a sweet, young girl with magical talents.

The premise, of a magical young woman who survives a disaster by being in suspended animation for 200 years and wants nothing more than too have a quiet life, only to discover she’s the only one capable of her branch of magic was a premise I was into as a manga reader myself. I love gentle fantasy and characters. See my review of Flying Witch as proof. But this gets actively destroyed by the introduction of slavery to the narrative.

The main character does moral gymnastics to justify her purchase of a human being.
I honestly have nothing I can say.

Slavery as a national form of economic development in the United States is only a century in the grave, and its wounds are still felt. Compound this with Japan’s own past as an imperialist power which committed atrocities. The enslavement of comfort women and manual laborers from surrounding territories in the 20th century is in the living memory of many Asians. The depiction of slavery in a work of fiction coming from Japan cannot be separated from the Japanese denial of responsibility for their atrocities, which has lasting socio-economic repercussions to this day.

Four Korean “comfort women” pose with a Chinese soldier in 1944. (Image: Pvt. Hatfield/U.S. Army/National Archives)

I love anime and manga, and I love so many facets of Japanese popular culture. Japan has many of its own wounds, perpetuated by the nation I was born in. But that does not mean I’m blind to all media from Japan and willing to accept it as something on my school library’s shelves. Slavery is still an issue in the 21st century, and no matter how sweet, talented, and wholesome a master may be, they are still a master. There’s no escaping reality here, and I won’t have books on my shelves that depict slavery as anything other than the highest form of moral depravity.

I’m pushing this out because I know Yen Press is going hard on this title. It was a giveaway at their panel at AnimeNYC, now considered the most prestigious anime convention in New York City. I have a notepad with the character and title on it that was given to me by Yen Press. I feel like the descriptions of this manga and marketing have in large part obfuscated the prevalence of the slavery subplot in the text. There are many other titles being published now that are far better suited for school libraries. Skipping out on this one title won’t have much of an impact.

One thought on “Manga Review: The Alchemist Who Survived Now Dreams of a Quiet Life (DO NOT PURCHASE)

  1. The fact that they branded him and that the binding incantation tells the victim that his life is worth as much as dirt strikes something raw.

    Heavy subjects like this have a place, they can be done well from a political and storytelling perspective to great effect. The inclusion of slavery itself doesn’t make it a horrible story. It is however, something that requires exceptional care to handle. By the tone of your review The Alchemist Who Survived Now Dreams of a Quiet Life doesn’t handle it with any sort of care at all.

    That is more than unfortunate.

    Works of this stripe have the opportunity to both recognize and condemn slavery, or at the very least deal with the issue in a manner that conveys its immorality. This can be done by simply taking any plots involving it to its logical conclusion; subjugation and subservience (willing or otherwise) and its impact on characters on either side.

    If the matter is glossed over, underutilized, or just used cheaply, it comes across as insensitive at best. Comparisons can be drawn with portrayals of abusive relationships, race/species relations, and crime.

    I appreciate your review, it might be worth reading for creators looking for examples of what NOT to do.

    Like

Leave a Reply to Marcus T. Williams (@Maromar15910) Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s